Penfolds Victoria Derby Day 29 Oct 2022

My Notebook

Schedule Tips Tickets

NETWORK 10 CARBINE CLUB STAKES

12:20 PM Finished 1600 3YO-G3
Track Rating
Weather
18° 18° / 10°

Results

Silk
1st
11. PERFECT THOUGHT
Silk
2nd
6. ELKINGTON ROAD
Silk
3rd
4. THE FORTUNE TELLER
Silk
4th
8. WATADEEL
Race 1 Overview

The biggest week of the racing year kicks off as always with the Carbine Club and has always the Guineas looks a good place to start. TIJUANA (1) was rock solid there, backing up his win in the Stutt Stakes, and there is little reason to think that he will drop away now. Stable won this with the very similar Crosshaven a few years back. THE FORTUNE TELLER (4) was sound on speed in the Guineas and has a shot at this with any luck from his wide draw. Alongside him is ELKINGTON ROAD (6) who ran a similar race at Caulfield and had similarly impressed at a lower level the start prior. Both should run well. The Gothic has thrown up five winners of the Carbine Club this century and SANDPAPER (2) toughed it out well enough there to consider him a chance of adding to that record. Speaking of good records, Chris Walelr has won this three times, including last year, and with J-Mac up PUNGO (12) looks the top seed of his three this time. Must consider.

Visit TAB.COM.AU
Choose Tipster
1
Silk
2. SANDPAPER Rtg 85 T: J Cummings   J: W Buick (58kg)
2
Silk
1. TIJUANA Rtg 100 T: Ben & J Hayes   J: M Zahra (58.5kg)
3
Silk
4. THE FORTUNE TELLER Rtg 93 T: C Maher & D Eustace   J: J Allen (57kg)
1
Silk
1. TIJUANA Rtg 100 T: Ben & J Hayes   J: M Zahra (58.5kg)
2
Silk
4. THE FORTUNE TELLER Rtg 93 T: C Maher & D Eustace   J: J Allen (57kg)
3
Silk
6. ELKINGTON ROAD Rtg 79 T: M Moroney   J: J Mott (57kg)
1
Silk
1. TIJUANA Rtg 100 T: Ben & J Hayes   J: M Zahra (58.5kg)
2
Silk
12. PUNGO Rtg 97 T: C Waller   J: J McDonald (57kg)
3
Silk
3. LIBERTY STEPS Rtg 67 T: Ben & J Hayes   J: D Oliver (57kg)
Visit TAB.COM.AU
FORM SUMMARY

The biggest week of the racing year kicks off as always with the Carbine Club and has always the Guineas looks a good place to start. TIJUANA (1) was rock solid there, backing up his win in the Stutt Stakes, and there is little reason to think that he will drop away now. Stable won this with the very similar Crosshaven a few years back. THE FORTUNE TELLER (4) was sound on speed in the Guineas and has a shot at this with any luck from his wide draw. Alongside him is ELKINGTON ROAD (6) who ran a similar race at Caulfield and had similarly impressed at a lower level the start prior. Both should run well. The Gothic has thrown up five winners of the Carbine Club this century and SANDPAPER (2) toughed it out well enough there to consider him a chance of adding to that record. Speaking of good records, Chris Waller has won this three times, including last year, and with J-Mac up PUNGO (12) looks the top seed of his three this time. Must consider.

Provided by Racing and Sports.

Runner (Barrier)
Trainer Jockey Form
My Pick

Just out of the placings last start; could run a better race here. On Oct 8 was 5th 0.8L, Golden Mile at Caulfield (Caulfield Guineas, 3YO-G1) 1600m. Two starts back he finished 1st 0.5L, Foujita San at Moonee Valley (Stutt Stakes, 3YO-G2) 1600m. Rates very well.

Career/Overall6: 3-2
Prize Money$406700.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeColt
Sire/DamAMERICAN PHAROAH (USA)-MEXICAN ROSE (NZ)
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position5
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 8Oct22
Race Distance1600m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyM.J.ZAHRA (57)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueMVAL
Date of MeetingFri 23Sep22
Race Distance1600m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyM.J.ZAHRA (57)
Finishing Position3
Racetrack/VenueFLEM
Date of MeetingSat 10Sep22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyM.J.DEE (58)
Finishing Position3
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 27Aug22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyM.J.DEE (58)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueFLEM
Date of MeetingMon 25Apr22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyM.J.ZAHRA (58)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenuePAKM
Date of MeetingThu 31Mar22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyM.J.DEE (58)

Lightly raced and a leading contender on last start win. Last run was 1st 0.2L, Angry Skies at Caulfield (Gothic Stakes, 3YO-LR) 1400m. Before that he finished 5th 1.8L, Kaygeebee at Moonee Valley (3Y-SWP) 1200m. One of the chances.

Career/Overall7: 2-1
Prize Money$175825.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeColt
Sire/DamSNITZEL-SMOOTH
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 15Oct22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyMS J.KAH (56)
Finishing Position5
Racetrack/VenueMVAL
Date of MeetingFri 23Sep22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyJ.B.MC DONALD (56)
Finishing Position8
Racetrack/VenueEFRM
Date of MeetingSat 4Jun22
Race Distance1500m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyJAMES ORMAN (57)
Finishing Position9
Racetrack/VenueEFRM
Date of MeetingSat 14May22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyJ.B.MC DONALD (57)
Finishing Position11
Racetrack/VenueRAND
Date of MeetingSat 26Feb22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyH.BOWMAN (55.5)
Finishing Position2
Racetrack/VenueRAND
Date of MeetingSat 12Feb22
Race Distance1100m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyH.BOWMAN (56)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueCANT
Date of MeetingFri 28Jan22
Race Distance1250m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyH.BOWMAN (57)

Last run finished 6th 5.2L, Sandpaper at Caulfield (Gothic Stakes, 3YO-LR) 1400m. Two back solid effort when 8th 2.8L, Kaygeebee at Moonee Valley (3Y-SWP) 1200m. Hard task here.

Career/Overall7: 1-2
Prize Money$109150.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeColt
Sire/DamSIDESTEP-LIBERTY JANE
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position6
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 15Oct22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyL.NOLEN (57)
Finishing Position8
Racetrack/VenueMVAL
Date of MeetingFri 23Sep22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyL.NOLEN (57)
Finishing Position5
Racetrack/VenueEFRM
Date of MeetingSat 4Jun22
Race Distance1500m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyC.WILLIAMS (57)
Finishing Position11
Racetrack/VenueEFRM
Date of MeetingSat 28May22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyB.MCDOUGALL (57)
Finishing Position2
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 7May22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyB.MCDOUGALL (58)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 16Apr22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyC.WILLIAMS (57)
Finishing Position3
Racetrack/VenueSANH
Date of MeetingWed 30Mar22
Race Distance1300m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyB.MCDOUGALL (58)

A win and a place from past four runs. Last start was 7th 1.3L, Golden Mile at Caulfield (Caulfield Guineas, 3YO-G1) 1600m. Two back was 2nd 1.3L, Bank Maur at Sandown-Hillside (3YO) 1400m. Has the ability.

Career/Overall4: 1-1
Prize Money$103500.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeColt
Sire/DamCARAVAGGIO (USA)-NATIONAL VELVET
ColourBR
Past Races
Finishing Position7
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 8Oct22
Race Distance1600m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyMS J.KAH (57)
Finishing Position2
Racetrack/VenueSANH
Date of MeetingSun 25Sep22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyMS J.KAH (54)
Finishing Position5
Racetrack/VenueSANH
Date of MeetingWed 7Sep22
Race Distance1300m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyJ.ALLEN (59.5)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueSHIL
Date of MeetingSun 7Aug22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyH.COFFEY (57)

Last run solid effort when 4th 2.7L, Sandpaper at Caulfield (Gothic Stakes, 3YO-LR) 1400m. On Sep 23 finished 3rd 0.9L, Kaygeebee at Moonee Valley (3Y-SWP) 1200m. Take on trust.

Career/Overall4: 1-1
Prize Money$92875.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeGelding
Sire/DamRUBICK-REDASUN
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position4
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 15Oct22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyJ.MC NEIL (57)
Finishing Position3
Racetrack/VenueMVAL
Date of MeetingFri 23Sep22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyK.MC EVOY (57)
Finishing Position12
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 27Aug22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyB.SHINN (57)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 7May22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyJ.MC NEIL (55)

Most recently he finished 10th 1.7L, Golden Mile at Caulfield (Caulfield Guineas, 3YO-G1) 1600m. On Sep 18 was 1st 0.1L, Desert Star at Flemington (3YB-64) 1420m. Win won't shock.

Career/Overall3: 2-0
Prize Money$60500.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeGelding
Sire/DamALL TOO HARD-SHERBET BOMB
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position10
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingSat 8Oct22
Race Distance1600m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyJ.MOTT (57)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueFLEM
Date of MeetingSun 18Sep22
Race Distance1420m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyJ.MOTT (60)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueSANL
Date of MeetingWed 31Aug22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyJ.MOTT (58)

Useful effort when 3rd last start. Last time out good run when 3rd 0.2L, Zoe's Promise at Caulfield (3YB-70) 1600m. On Sep 28 good run when he finished 3rd 1.5L, Mensa Missile at Rosehill (BM-72) 1400m. Could find best.

Career/Overall4: 1-3
Prize Money$65150.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeColt
Sire/DamREDOUTE'S CHOICE-WIENER
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position3
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingWed 12Oct22
Race Distance1600m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyJ.B.MC DONALD (58)
Finishing Position3
Racetrack/VenueROSE
Date of MeetingWed 28Sep22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyK.MC EVOY (55)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueWFRM
Date of MeetingWed 14Sep22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyH.BOWMAN (59)
Finishing Position2
Racetrack/VenueWFRM
Date of MeetingWed 31Aug22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyT.BERRY (59)

Good run when second last start. On Oct 12 he finished 2nd 0.1L, Zoe's Promise at Caulfield (3YB-70) 1600m. Two runs back was 1st 2.8L, Paris Affair at Geelong (3Y-MSW) 1325m. Worth consideration.

Career/Overall3: 1-1
Prize Money$49375.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeGelding
Sire/DamDUNDEEL (NZ)-WATER KISS
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position2
Racetrack/VenueCAUL
Date of MeetingWed 12Oct22
Race Distance1600m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyMS J.KAH (57)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueGEEL
Date of MeetingThu 15Sep22
Race Distance1325m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyZ.SPAIN (58)
Finishing Position4
Racetrack/VenuePAKM
Date of MeetingThu 19May22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyZ.SPAIN (58)

Last run finished very strongly 2nd 5L, More Reward at Morphettville (Hill Smith Stakes, 3YO-LR) 1800m. Before that solid effort when he finished 4th 3.7L, Castillian at Moonee Valley (3YO) 1500m. Can place here.

Career/Overall4: 1-1
Prize Money$47674.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeGelding
Sire/DamWHAT'S THE STORY-ISOLA BELLA (NZ)
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position2
Racetrack/VenueMORP
Date of MeetingSat 8Oct22
Race Distance1800m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyT.PANNELL (57)
Finishing Position4
Racetrack/VenueMVAL
Date of MeetingSat 3Sep22
Race Distance1500m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyD.LANE (58)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueBRTS
Date of MeetingFri 19Aug22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyD.LANE (58)
Finishing Position8
Racetrack/VenueAVD
Date of MeetingSat 2Apr22
Race Distance1300m
Track ConditionDead
JockeyA.J.CALDER (57)

Last time out he finished 9th 10.1L, Williamsburg at Randwick (Dulcify Stakes, 3YO-LR) 1600m. Before that finished 2nd 0.5L, Savoury at Warwick Farm (BM-72) 1400m. Not worst here.

Career/Overall6: 1-2
Prize Money$44550.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeColt
Sire/DamLONHRO-SELF ESTEEM
ColourBR
Past Races
Finishing Position9
Racetrack/VenueRAND
Date of MeetingSat 1Oct22
Race Distance1600m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyJ.R.COLLETT (56.5)
Finishing Position2
Racetrack/VenueWFRM
Date of MeetingWed 14Sep22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyK.MC EVOY (54)
Finishing Position2
Racetrack/VenueWFRM
Date of MeetingWed 31Aug22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyJ.B.MC DONALD (59.5)
Finishing Position6
Racetrack/VenueSANL
Date of MeetingWed 1Jun22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyD.THORNTON (59)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenuePAKM
Date of MeetingThu 19May22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyD.THORNTON (58)
Finishing Position7
Racetrack/VenueWFRM
Date of MeetingWed 27Apr22
Race Distance1100m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyJ.PARR (57)

On Oct 11 was 3rd 3.3L, Mcgeehan at Newcastle (BM-68) 1500m. On Sep 24 was 4th 4.5L, Sailor at Newcastle (3Y+CL1) 1400m. Lacks appeal.

Career/Overall5: 1-1
Prize Money$40175.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeColt
Sire/DamSO YOU THINK (NZ)-PERFECTLY SAFE
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position3
Racetrack/VenueNEWC
Date of MeetingTue 11Oct22
Race Distance1500m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyW.PIKE (55)
Finishing Position4
Racetrack/VenueNEWC
Date of MeetingSat 24Sep22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyK.S.LATHAM (56.5)
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueKEMB
Date of MeetingSat 27Aug22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionSoft
JockeyK.S.LATHAM (59.5)
Finishing Position8
Racetrack/VenueRANI
Date of MeetingWed 10Aug22
Race Distance1300m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyT.BERRY (57.5)
Finishing Position4
Racetrack/VenueFLEM
Date of MeetingMon 25Apr22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyC.WILLIAMS (57)

Strong winner last start at second run this preparation. On Oct 12 he finished 1st 3L, In Love And War at Warwick Farm (3Y+Maiden) 1400m. Two starts back ran strongly 5th 2.4L, Saturn Star at Rosehill (3Y-Maiden) 1200m. Conditions favour.

Career/Overall2: 1-0
Prize Money$27650.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeColt
Sire/DamSO YOU THINK (NZ)-UZAYLI
ColourBR
Past Races
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueWFRM
Date of MeetingWed 12Oct22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionHeavy
JockeyH.BOWMAN (56)
Finishing Position5
Racetrack/VenueROSE
Date of MeetingWed 28Sep22
Race Distance1200m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyH.BOWMAN (58)

On Oct 11 he finished 1st 2.3L, Jet De Lune at Echuca (3Y+MSW) 1400m. Worth watching.

Career/Overall1: 1-0
Prize Money$14850.00
Age3 yo
Sex/TypeGelding
Sire/DamFIORENTE (IRE)-ANY DANE NOW
ColourB
Past Races
Finishing Position1
Racetrack/VenueECHA
Date of MeetingTue 11Oct22
Race Distance1400m
Track ConditionGood
JockeyH.COFFEY (57)
Runner/Barrier
Leader
Midfield
Backmarker
Silk
1
TIJUANA (2)
Silk
2
SANDPAPER (5)
Silk
3
LIBERTY STEPS (4)
Silk
4
THE FORTUNE TELLER (11)
Silk
5
LINCOLN SQUARE (6)
Silk
6
ELKINGTON ROAD (10)
Silk
7
REDIENER (7)
Silk
8
WATADEEL (9)
Silk
9
BIG STORY (12)
Silk
10
LINDERMANN (6)
Silk
11
PERFECT THOUGHT (8)
Silk
12
PUNGO (1)
Silk
13
MY BROTHERS KEEPER (3)
Visit TAB.COM.AU